Temperance movements: Battling alcoholism throughout history

The battle against alcohol addiction and abuse is as old as the drink itself. While many regard the issues surrounding alcohol as a modern problem, the truth is that concerns over excessive drinking have been present for centuries. One of the most notable responses to this persistent issue has been the rise of temperance movements. These grassroots campaigns, driven by an array of socio-cultural and religious factors, have sought to curb the consumption of alcohol and address the societal damage it can cause.

By understanding the origins and motivations of these movements, we gain a deeper appreciation for the enduring challenge of alcohol addiction and the myriad ways society has attempted to mitigate its effects.

Alcohol in Britain

As industrialisation rapidly transformed societies in Europe and North America, the consumption of alcohol grew considerably. This rise was not merely a product of changing lifestyles but also of increasing alcohol production and availability. Britain’s struggles with alcohol grew yearly, perhaps most infamously during the “Gin Craze.”

The British Gin Craze

In Britain, the Gin Craze of the early 18th century gave a taste of what mass alcohol consumption could lead to. Due to changes in laws that made it easier to produce and sell gin, coupled with heavy taxes on imported spirits and beers, gin became the drink of choice for many, especially in London.

This rampant consumption led to social issues, including increased crime, poverty and mortality rates. One of the most tragic stories from the time was that of Judith Defour, who was hanged in 1734 for murdering her young daughter so she could use her clothing for gin money.

The case drew widespread attention and highlighted the devastating societal impact of rampant alcohol consumption and addiction. Her story was frequently invoked as evidence of the moral decay and desperation brought on by alcohol abuse and contributed to legislative measures like the Gin Acts to curb gin production and consumption.

Battling alcoholism throughout history picture
William Hogarth’s famous depiction of London’s Gin Lane, 1751

The Origins of the British Temperance Movement

As 19th-century urban Britain continued to grapple with widespread drinking, the British Temperance Movement emerged in response to the detrimental effects on families and society.

The first official society, the Preston Temperance Society, was founded in 1832 by Joseph Livesey, who is often regarded as the father of British temperance. Livesey and six other men took a pledge outside a Preston pub to abstain from hard spirits, marking the birth of organised temperance advocacy in Britain.

The driving force behind the temperance movement was a blend of social, religious and economic concerns. The widespread devastation that excessive drinking brought upon families, particularly among the working class, was evident as spousal abuse, child neglect and poverty were directly linked to alcohol addiction. Religious groups, especially nonconformist denominations like the Methodists, saw alcohol as the root of moral decay and rallied behind the cause.

The Match Girls Strike

One notable event from this era was the 1888 match girl’s strike in London. The workers, primarily young women, were protesting against poor working conditions, including the dangers of working with white phosphorus. Annie Besant, a leading figure in the strike, noted the prevalence of drinking among these workers, many of whom spent their meagre wages on alcohol to escape their dreary lives. The temperance movement saw such scenarios as evidence of the pressing need for their cause.
Alcoholism in America image

America’s Alcohol Struggles

Around the same time, the newly formed United States, with its vast territories and enterprising spirit, was facing its struggles with alcohol. One notable episode that highlights the nation’s intricate relationship with alcohol and the rising awareness of its harmful societal effects is the Whiskey Rebellion of 1974.

The Whiskey Rebellion

The Whiskey Rebellion was a violent tax protest in the United States during the early 1790s. The federal government, under the leadership of Secretary of the Treasury Alexander Hamilton, imposed a tax on distilled spirits to help pay off the national debt. This tax was strongly opposed, especially by frontier farmers who often distilled their surplus grain into whiskey. In 1794, tensions culminated in an armed rebellion in western Pennsylvania, prompting President George Washington to lead a militia force to suppress the uprising, showcasing the young federal government’s determination to maintain order and authority.

The Rise of American Temperance Societies

By the early 19th century, concerns about alcohol’s detrimental effects began to surface. The American Temperance Society, founded in 1826, was one of the earliest organised efforts to curtail alcohol consumption. Their approach mirrored that of their British counterparts, emphasising the moral, economic and social costs of drinking. By the 1830s, these societies had gained significant momentum, boasting over a million members.

One notable example of early American Temperance occurred in Portland, Maine, where a man named Neal Dow, later known as the “Napoleon of Temperance”, was alarmed at the levels of alcohol consumption he observed. In 1851, leveraging his position as mayor, Dow successfully pushed for the “Maine Law”, which effectively prohibited the production and sale of alcohol in the state. This became a template for other states and Dow’s influence was felt far and wide as he toured the nation, promoting the temperance cause.

The Prohibition Era

While a comprehensive exploration of the Prohibition era deserves its own article, it’s crucial to recognise its origins in the 19th-century temperance movements. The Prohibition of alcohol, which commenced in 1920 with the 18th Amendment, marked the culmination of decades of dedicated activism against the consumption of alcoholic beverages.

These concerns weren’t just about drunkenness; they were about the broader societal ills attributed to alcohol, from domestic violence to poverty to the perceived moral decay of the nation. Religious groups, especially the Methodists, and organisations like the Women’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) and the Anti-Saloon League spearheaded the fight against the “Demon Rum,” leading the charge for a nationwide ban on alcohol.

The Modern Temperance Movement

The modern temperance movement, rather than advocating for outright bans, has often focused on education, prevention and providing resources for those struggling with alcohol addiction. This approach recognises that while legislative solutions can be part of the equation, a more holistic approach is necessary to address the root causes of alcoholism and excessive drinking.

Public Health Awareness Efforts

One of the most significant shifts has been framing alcohol addiction as a public health issue. Global organisations like the World Health Organization (WHO) and recovery organisations like UKAT emphasise the global impact of alcohol-related harm. The WHO’s Global Strategy to Reduce the Harmful Use of Alcohol, for instance, addresses alcohol’s role in accidents, injuries and various diseases.

This increase in public awareness can effectively curb excessive drinking and the risk of alcohol addiction. One recent example of this is the “Dry January” initiative. Originating in the UK, this challenge encourages participants to abstain from alcohol for the month of January. Its popularity has grown exponentially, with millions now taking part worldwide.

Alcohol Education

School and community programmes that educate youth about the dangers of excessive drinking and alcohol addiction have become widespread. These programmes aim to prevent alcohol addiction before it starts, providing young people with the tools and knowledge to make informed decisions about alcohol. UKAT provides school programmes across the UK where our addiction experts talk to students and educators about the dangers of alcohol and how to make more informed choices.

Support Groups

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), founded in 1935, has become synonymous with the fight against alcohol addiction in the modern era. This fellowship allows those struggling with alcohol addiction to come together, share their experiences and support one another in their recovery journeys. The success of AA has spawned many similar programmes and support groups worldwide.

Treatment and Rehabilitation

As our understanding of alcohol addiction has evolved, so too have our treatment methods. Alcohol rehabilitation centres like UKAT now offer medical, psychological and social support for those trying to overcome alcohol addiction. Unlike early Temperance Movements, the recovery approach no longer stigmatises those suffering from alcohol addiction. Instead, understanding, evidence-based treatment and ongoing support and assistance are provided to give people the best chance of recovery.

Policy Adjustments

While outright bans on alcohol are rare, many countries have adopted policies to reduce alcohol’s societal impact. In the UK, these include regulations on advertising, increased taxes on alcoholic products, stricter age verification checks and more stringent penalties for drunk driving.

Final Thoughts

Centuries of advocacy against alcohol addiction have laid the foundation for today’s comprehensive recovery efforts. Building on the work done by early Temperance Movements and with the advantage of scientific insight, therapeutic practices and increased awareness, organisations like Oasis Bradford and our other UKAT centres offer holistic approaches that not only treat the symptoms of alcohol addiction but also target its underlying causes. Gone are the days of stigmatisation and punitive measures; the focus now is on understanding, empathy and evidence-based interventions.

If you or someone you love is in need of help with alcohol addiction, contact Oasis Bradford today. We can help you take the first step towards recovery.

(Click here to see works cited)